Exclusive: Prosecutor freezes accounts of ex-Vatican bank heads

Reuters
By Philip Pullella
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - The Vatican's top prosecutor has frozen 16 million euros in bank accounts owned by two former Vatican bank managers and a lawyer as part of an investigation into the sale of Vatican-owned real estate in the 2000s, according to the freezing order and other legal documents.
Prosecutor Gian Piero Milano said he suspected the three men, former bank president Angelo Caloia, ex-director general Lelio Scaletti, and lawyer Gabriele Liuzzo, of embezzling money while managing the sale of 29 buildings sold by the Vatican bank to mainly Italian buyers between 2001 and 2008, according to a copy of the freezing order reviewed by Reuters.
The money in the three men's bank accounts "stems from embezzlement they were engaged in," Milano said in the October 27 sequester order.
Milano's investigation follows an audit of the Vatican bank by non-Vatican financial consultants commissioned last year by the bank's current management. The Vatican bank earlier this year also filed a legal complaint against the three men. The men have not been charged.
The Vatican spokesman on Saturday issued a statement confirming the freezing but gave no names, amounts or other details.
The Vatican bank said in a separate statement that it had pressed charges against the three as part of its "commitment to transparency and zero tolerance, including with regard to matters that relate to a more distant past". The bank statement also gave no details, citing "the ongoing judicial enquiry".
The investigation is part of a drive to improve the transparency of the Vatican administration and finances, an endeavor that has accelerated under Pope Francis. The Argentine pontiff was elected in 2013 with a mandate to make the Roman Catholic Church more accountable to its 1.2 billion faithful.
Liuzzo, 91, confirmed in a telephone interview that his bank accounts had been frozen. He said the prosecutor’s allegations were "rubbish" and that all money from the sales of the buildings had gone to the bank.
Caloia, 75, did not respond to emailed questions and phone calls to his home and office requesting comment. Scaletti, 88, did not respond to messages left at his home.
The period relating to property sales covers seven years, and two papacies, when the Vatican's administration often operated without oversight.
INFLUENTIAL BANK
John Paul II was incapacitated by illness for years before his death in 2005. His successor, former Pope Benedict, is a theologian who Vatican officials say did not focus on management issues.
During these years, the Curia, as the Church's central administration is known, was marked by feuding among Vatican departments and leaks of papal documents. The tensions were a reason Benedict resigned in early 2013, people close to the former pope say.
The bank, officially known as the Institute for Works of Religion (IOR), is the core of Vatican finances, but its influence stretches beyond Holy See walls, because of tight relations between the religious city-state and Italy.
In recent years, it has changed management and closed hundreds of accounts in order to comply with international anti-money-laundering and anti-financial crimes laws.
Last year, Ernst von Freyberg, a German businessman who ran the bank from March 2013 to July 2014 and worked to apply international financial standards, commissioned an independent audit of the sale of properties that had been owned by the bank.
The audit, which was reviewed by Reuters, details the sales of the 29 buildings, which are largely in Rome and Milan.
In the freezing order, Milano said Caloia and Scaletti regularly under-represented the proceeds from real estate sales in the Vatican bank’s official books. The men allegedly received the difference between the real sale prices and the amount officially recorded separately and often in cash, according to the order.
Some of the proceeds were deposited in a Rome bank account that was not registered in the bank's balance sheet, the prosecutor said. An estimated 57 million euros were allegedly siphoned off illegally between 2001 and 2008, he said. Liuzzi, the legal consultant, received part of the funds, the freezing order added.
In the phone interview, Liuzzi said he had always acted according to the orders of the bank president and director general.
It is not clear whether Milano has finished his investigation. According to a person close to the probe, the prosecutor could seek to involve Italian authorities because most of the sales took place in Italy.
(additional reporting by Alessandra Galloni and Paolo Biondi, editing by Alessandra Galloni and Janet McBride)
View Comments (302)

World

  • Exclusive: Prosecutor freezes accounts of ex-Vatican bank heads

    By Philip Pullella VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - The Vatican's top prosecutor has frozen 16 million euros in bank accounts owned by two former Vatican bank managers and a lawyer as part of an investigation into the sale of Vatican-owned real estate in the 2000s, according to the freezing order and other…
    Reuters
  • Buy Blackberry Q10 on Konga.com!

    Buy the New BlackBerry Q10 with classic BlackBerry Keyboard re-engineered for effortless typing on Konga, Nigeria largest online Mall at best prices.
    AdChoicesKonga.comSponsored
  • Clashes erupt in Athens after protest to mark 2008 police killing

    By Renee Maltezou ATHENS (Reuters) - Rampaging protesters threw petrol bombs at police and set bank ATMs, cars and shops on fire in central Athens on Saturday, the anniversary of the police killing of a teenager six years ago. Riot police used teargas and water cannon to beat back protesters in the…
    Reuters
  • Egypt court sentences seven jihadists to death in Sinai case

    CAIRO (Reuters) - An Egyptian court has sentenced to death seven men, including prominent Islamist militant Adel Habara, over the killing of 25 policemen last year in an attack near the border with Israel, judicial sources said on Saturday. The attack took place in August 2013 following the…
    Reuters
  • Panel lets Chris Christie off 'Bridgegate' hook. Is he, really?

    New Jersey Governor Chris Christie’s presidential prospects – already pretty good compared to other Republicans with White House dreams – got a boost with the latest report on the “Bridgegate” scandal.
    Christian Science Monitor
  • What UVA journalists take away from Rolling Stone apology

    In the week before finals, University of Virginia campus reporters got an unexpected, front-row lesson in Journalism 101.
    Christian Science Monitor
  • Obama’s black cabinet heads spar over racial profiling ban

    The first major revisions of US racial profiling rules in over a decade required the African-American men who steer the United States government to check their own civil rights ideals against the demands of national defense.
    Christian Science Monitor
  • Eric Garner: Chokehold his own doing, or 'death by economic regulation'?

    Protesters have clung to Eric Garner’s last words – “I can’t breathe” – as they demonstrate against what they see as unequal application of justice after a grand jury this week refused to hand down homicide charges against NYPD Officer Dan Pantaleo, whose chokehold killed Garner.
    Christian Science Monitor
  • 10 Things to See: A week of top AP photos

    Here's your look at highlights from the weekly AP photo report, a gallery featuring a mix of front-page photography, the odd image you might have missed and lasting moments our editors think you should see.
    Associated Press
  • Yemen rescue failed as captors alerted to approaching U.S. commandos: officials

    By Jeff Mason and Mohammed Ghobari WASHINGTON/SANAA (Reuters) - It could have been something as simple as a barking dog that alerted the al Qaeda guards as U.S. special operations forces approached the compound just after midnight. Within seconds, as they neared the building, intense gunfire…
    Reuters19 mins ago
  • 2nd blogger detained in Vietnam crackdown

    HANOI, Vietnam (AP) — Vietnamese police detained a second blogger in a week in the latest crackdown on dissent in the Communist country.
    Associated Press10 mins ago
  • Women's Champs Trophy final: Argentina vs Aussies

    MENDOZA, Argentina (AP) — Luciana Aymar will bow out of international field hockey with another title shot after Argentina edged the Netherlands 2-1 in a thriller to reach the Women's Champions Trophy final on Saturday.
    Associated Press29 mins ago
  • Reichelt holds off Jansrud in World Cup super-G

    BEAVER CREEK, Colo. (AP) — This is how Hannes Reichelt prefers his courses: daunting, with a dash of demanding and a bit of danger.
    Associated Press38 mins ago
  • Powerful typhoon slams into eastern Philippines

    LEGAZPI, Philippines (AP) — Typhoon Hagupit slammed into the central Philippines' east coast late Saturday, knocking out power and toppling trees in a region where 650,000 people have fled to safety, still haunted by the massive death and destruction wrought by a monster storm last year.
    Associated Press43 mins ago
  • Top Asian News at 12:00 a.m. GMT

    LEGAZPI, Philippines (AP) — Typhoon Hagupit slammed into the central Philippines' east coast late Saturday, knocking out power and toppling trees in a region where 650,000 people have fled to safety, still haunted by the massive death and destruction wrought by a monster storm last year. Packing…
    Associated Press44 mins ago
  • Magnitude 6.0 quake hits east of Indonesia

    NEW YORK (AP) — The U.S. Geological Survey says a magnitude 6.0 underwater quake has struck off east Indonesia, but no tsunami warnings have been posted.
    Associated Press51 mins ago
  • Mexico: At least 1 of 43 missing students ID'd

    MEXICO CITY (AP) — At least one of 43 college students missing since September has been identified among charred remains found near a garbage dump, two Mexican officials confirmed Saturday.
    Associated Press
  • Star distance swimmer Hackett planning comeback

    SYDNEY (AP) — Former world and Olympic champion Grant Hackett is planning a limited comeback to competitive swimming six years after his retirement and eight months after completing rehab for his addiction to sleeping pills.
    Associated Press
  • Benfica, Porto win big to set up clash in Portugal

    LISBON, Portugal (AP) — Benfica and Porto both earned commanding wins in the Portuguese league on Saturday as they prepared to meet in the following round.
    Associated Press